Benedict's concern about the priest is understandable. A priest entering a monastery already possesses an identity, authority, education, sacramental role, and perhaps considerable social standing. Benedict does not reject any of that. But neither will he allow it to determine the priest's place in the community. The priest must become, once again, a beginner. He enters under the Rule just as everyone else does.
That ancient insistence has considerable depth.
The Desert Fathers repeatedly return to something very similar. The person seeking God must relinquish the need to establish who he is, what he knows, and what he has accomplished. Abba Moses, Abba Poemen, and the other desert elders are remarkably suspicious of spiritual self-certainty. Wisdom begins not in knowing that we have arrived, but in recognizing how much remains to be surrendered.
John Cassian carries the thought further. Renunciation is not merely abandoning possessions. There is an interior renunciation—the relinquishment of the habits, assumptions, desires, and self-images by which we have constructed ourselves.
And there is an important connection with the Tao Te Ching passage Sister Joan introduces. Read gently, "emptying people's minds" need not mean destroying intelligence or individuality. It can suggest emptying ourselves of our insistence upon knowing—particularly our certainty that our previous categories must govern what comes next.
And perhaps every one of us stands before each new day under the same summons:
...if we cling to the past, the future is closed to us,
becomes much more than advice about adaptability. It becomes a statement about conversion.
However, Benedict is actually deeply respectful of memory, tradition, Scripture, inherited wisdom, and stability. He does not ask us to become people without histories. Rather, he asks us not to be imprisoned by our histories. We do not deny what we have been. We surrender our demand that what we have been must determine what we are becoming.
Benedictine conversatio suggests precisely this lifelong willingness to be converted—to allow God, community, circumstance, failure, prayer, work, age, and grace to continually reshape us.
And then, Benedict adds something quite beautiful: beneath all that change stands stability. We stay—and because we stay, we change. We remain with the community, the prayer, the discipline, and the search for God long enough for them to transform us. A seeming paradox that leads to our conversion. Benedict asks us to be stable enough to change.
We are called to begin again each day—not by denying what has been, but by refusing to be imprisoned by it. Stable enough to change, humble enough to learn again, and empty enough to receive what God has not yet revealed. If we cling to the past, the future closes before us. But if we open our hands, what we have been can become the soil from which God forms what we are still becoming.